Obsidian-bin AUR Deletion: What You Need To Know

Hey Obsidian users!

If you're using the obsidian-bin package from the Arch User Repository (AUR), you'll want to pay close attention to this. There's a possibility that this package might be removed from the AUR in the near future. While "soon" might not mean tomorrow, it's definitely something you should be aware of and prepare for. Let's dive into the details and see what this means for you and your Obsidian setup.

Why is obsidian-bin at Risk?

The main reason for the potential deletion stems from a violation of AUR packaging rules. The obsidian-bin package, as the name suggests, distributes pre-built binaries of Obsidian. This approach, while convenient for some users, goes against the AUR guidelines that favor building packages from source. Distributing binaries can raise concerns about transparency and security since users aren't able to verify the build process themselves. Think of it like buying a pre-assembled computer versus building one yourself. With the pre-built one, you trust the manufacturer, but building it yourself lets you know exactly what's inside.

This issue was brought to light in June 2025, as noted in this Arch Linux mailing list archive. The discussion highlights the rule violation and sets the stage for a potential deletion request. So, what does this mean for you? It means it's time to consider alternatives and ensure your Obsidian setup remains smooth and uninterrupted.

Understanding the AUR and Its Rules

For those new to the Arch Linux ecosystem or the AUR, let's quickly break down what these are and why these rules matter. Arch Linux is a distribution known for its flexibility, its "keep it simple, stupid" (KISS) philosophy, and its rolling-release model. The AUR is a community-driven repository where users can share package build descriptions (PKGBUILDs) for software not available in the official repositories. This is fantastic because it opens up a vast library of software. However, this also means that packages need to adhere to certain guidelines to ensure quality and security.

One of the key rules is that packages should ideally be built from source. This means that the PKGBUILD should download the source code of the software and compile it on the user's machine. This allows users to inspect the code, verify its integrity, and ensure that no malicious code is being introduced. Binary packages, on the other hand, skip this step and simply install pre-compiled executables. While this can be faster, it bypasses the important step of verifying the source. The obsidian-bin package falls into this category, which is why it's now facing a deletion request.

The Implications of Deletion

So, what happens if obsidian-bin is removed from the AUR? If you're currently using it, your Obsidian installation won't magically disappear overnight. However, you won't receive any further updates through the AUR. This means you'll miss out on new features, bug fixes, and security patches. Over time, this can lead to compatibility issues and potential vulnerabilities. It's like using an outdated app on your phone – eventually, it might stop working correctly or become a security risk.

Additionally, if you ever need to reinstall Obsidian or set it up on a new machine, you won't be able to use the obsidian-bin package anymore. This could be a hassle, especially if you're used to the convenience of the AUR. Therefore, it's crucial to take proactive steps now to transition to a different installation method.

What Are Your Alternatives?

Okay, so obsidian-bin might be on its way out. What are your options? Don't worry; you've got a couple of good alternatives to keep your Obsidian workflow running smoothly. Let's explore them:

1. The Official Obsidian AUR Package

The most straightforward alternative is the official obsidian package in the AUR. This package builds Obsidian from source, which aligns with the AUR guidelines. This means you get all the benefits of using the AUR while also ensuring you're using a package that adheres to best practices. Think of it as the "approved" way to install Obsidian on Arch Linux. To switch to this package, you'll need to uninstall obsidian-bin and install obsidian. It might take a bit longer to install since it needs to compile from source, but it's a one-time process.

Here's a quick rundown of the steps:

1. Uninstall obsidian-bin: yay -R obsidian-bin (or use your preferred AUR helper)
2. Install obsidian: yay -S obsidian

Remember, building from source means your system will need the necessary dependencies and might take some time depending on your hardware. But once it's done, you're set!

2. AppImage

Another excellent option is using the AppImage version of Obsidian. AppImages are self-contained packages that include all the dependencies needed to run an application. This means you don't have to worry about system libraries or compatibility issues. It's like having a portable version of Obsidian that you can run anywhere. AppImages are super convenient because they don't require installation in the traditional sense. You simply download the AppImage, make it executable, and run it.

Here's how to get started with the AppImage:

1. Download the latest Obsidian AppImage from the official Obsidian website.
2. Make the AppImage executable: chmod +x Obsidian-*.AppImage
3. Run Obsidian: ./Obsidian-*.AppImage

The first time you run the AppImage, it might ask you if you want to integrate it with your system. This will add Obsidian to your application menu and make it easier to launch. The AppImage is a fantastic option if you want a hassle-free way to run Obsidian without dealing with package managers or dependencies.

Comparing the Alternatives

Choosing between the official obsidian package and the AppImage depends on your preferences. If you prefer the AUR and building from source, the official package is the way to go. If you want a portable, self-contained option, the AppImage is an excellent choice. Guys, both options will keep you productive with Obsidian, so it's really about what fits best into your workflow.

Key Takeaways and Recommendations

Alright, let's wrap things up with some key takeaways and recommendations to ensure you're well-prepared for the potential removal of obsidian-bin:

• Be Aware: The obsidian-bin package on the AUR might be deleted due to AUR rule violations.
• Plan Ahead: Don't wait until the last minute. Start considering your alternatives now.
• Official Package: The official obsidian package is the recommended alternative for AUR users.
• AppImage: The AppImage is a great option for a portable, dependency-free experience.
• Stay Updated: Keep an eye on the Arch Linux community forums and mailing lists for any updates on this issue.

Recommendations:

1. If you're currently using obsidian-bin: Begin the transition to either the official obsidian package or the AppImage. Test both options to see which one works best for you.
2. If you're new to Obsidian on Arch Linux: Skip obsidian-bin altogether and go straight for the official package or the AppImage.
3. Backup Your Vault: Regardless of which installation method you choose, always back up your Obsidian vault regularly. This ensures you won't lose your valuable notes and information.

Final Thoughts

The potential removal of obsidian-bin from the AUR is a good reminder of the importance of adhering to community guidelines and best practices. While it might seem like a minor inconvenience, it's an opportunity to ensure your Obsidian setup is robust and future-proof. By taking proactive steps now, you can avoid any disruptions and continue enjoying the powerful note-taking capabilities of Obsidian on Arch Linux. So, let's get those vaults migrated and keep our knowledge organized, guys! And hey, if you have any questions or run into any issues, don't hesitate to reach out to the Arch Linux and Obsidian communities for help. We're all in this together!

Happy note-taking!